March 16, 2004

One tawdry tale from the horse world that won't fade away is the
equine insurance scandal of the 1990s, where a number of expensive
show horses were killed in order for their owners to collect on
insurance mortality coverage. The sordid saga was best portrayed
in author Ken Englade's book Hot Blood (St. Martin's Paperbacks).
One of the high-profile equestrians ensnared in the scandal was
Paul Valliere, who was considered one of the top equitation coaches
in America. In 1994 he admitted in federal court that he paid to have
his own horse electrocuted in order to collect $75,000 from his horse's
insurer.
 
Due to cooperating with the government, including wearing a wire to
help bring 23 grand jury indictments against other participants in the
horse killing scam, Valliere never served jail time. But he was placed
on probation and was given a 10-year suspension from participating or
officiating at USEF (then the American Horse Shows Association) events.
 
Fast forward to the Equus Medal Class, a special sort of horsemanship
class held annually at the showgrounds in Wellington, Fla. Though not
sanctioned by USEF, the Equus Medal draws upper echelon competitors
who have competed internationally for the United States in show
jumping events. Organizer Mason Phelps, Jr. invited Paul Valliere,
whose USEF suspension is nearing the time for re-evaluation, to be
one of a trio of judges for the March 8th event. Apparently the choice
did not sit well with a vocal group of English equestrians and horse
lovers who complained loudly via an Internet bulletin board hosted by
The Chronicle of the Horse weekly magazine (
www.chronofhorse.com).
More than a few phone calls and e-mails reached the Equus Medal
organizers. Paul Valliere was said to have graciously stepped down
from the judging assignment, being replaced by Leo Conroy. But there
can be no denying that the protestations had some hand in the decision.
 
The entire brouhaha adds to speculation as to whether or not Paul
Valliereand any other of the participants even remotely involved in
the horse insurance scandalwill ever redeem themselves in the eyes
of the grassroots equestrian community. Despite a record of charitable
work with horses, admitted regret for his actions and a bevy of riders
eager for his coaching, forgiveness still seems to elude the once revered
horseman. -Cindy Hale